Now that I've decided to keep the GX550 long-term, back to getting ready to order MT64 or BP51. I may have missed on a thread somewhere, but has anyone provided a review on BP51 highway ride and handling vs stock OT+ suspension? Plenty of great info on MT64 on this forum but looking for real world reviews on the BP51.
I have MT64 on my GX550 and BP51 on my Jeep JK.
My next jeep shocks will probably be the MT64.
I think the BP51 has some good qualities but some nasty cons that should be considered-
From a ride perspective, the MT64 is good, solid, reliable and comes factory tuned for a wide range of use cases.
The BP51 is solid but requires tuning to get right and tuning isn't trivial with the 2 adjusters per shock. I never really managed to figure out an optimal setting. Got it to be "good enough".
The reservoir works great in terms of heat dissipation on long fast washboards, but the MT64 is so big I doubt it has any issue with what you'd do with the GX despite the lack of reservoirs. Also lack of reservoirs means better reliability which is definitely something I want in my GX.
I don't know how many places in the US can rebuild the BP51 if needed. MT64 is much more available in terms of local supply and I'd just get a new one if I ever have to. I had to wait a month to get my delivery allocation of BP51 (2 years ago).
As for actual adjustments and usage - you're not going to use the adjustment rings. They're the least practical rings to adjust I've seen. They're poorly accessible and impossible to turn. The O-rings are tight and the tool they give you will leave your hands hurting. And the story about "adjust it while you're airing up/down entering/leaving the trail"- no way. You're not going to lie on your back in the dirt trying to find an access point that gives you enough leverage to adjust those things.
Fox/King/ADS - they all seem to have easily adjustable knobs, so I don't know what's going on here.
Also the compression vs rebound settings - I have no idea what I'm doing tuning one vs the other.
It's likely that you can adjust the BP51 to be better than the MT64 on the road and then tune it to be better on the trail, but the MT64 just works well on both as far as I could manage to adjust it.
Having said all this- they're both very well constructed. They both seem like they could take a beating, and the finish on both of them is very durable.
I did dump the silly little plastic "rock protection cover" that comes with both (it just broke the first time it actually saw a rock) and replaced it with a generic rubber boot. Yet another thing that the BP51 adjusters make inconvenient - as the adjustment knobs are exactly where you'd normally want the rubber boot to hold the shock body.